Compare willie loman and jay gatsby

Great Gatsby & Death of a Salesman: Comparison

Despite attaining the American Dream by becoming extremely wealthy and entering the upper class, Jay Gatsby becomes corrupted by wealth and is not able to provide stability Compare willie loman and jay gatsby Daisy. This is true, not because the dream is a failure or even leads to failure, but because some people who are given the opportunity to make themselves into heroes will gladly wear the clothes of the hero but are not morally strong enough to admit honestly that they were not quite good enough to be a hero.

Ultimately both Fitzgerald and Miller see the American Dream as a failure. For Jay Gatsby, obtaining the material dream is a means to personal fulfilment, but for Willy Loman this concept is reversed: The Dream consumed people to the extent that they cheated in order to obtain it.

Bevor Sie fortfahren...

When we compare his self-presentation to the facts of his career and his personality, we have to conclude that he is, in a way, a fraud. If the American Dream is one of economic self-creation or self-determination, these men present a failed alternative.

Gatsby was used in life, but forgotton in death when the party was over. Jay Gatsby, in The Great Gatsby, pursues a vision of success and becomes a criminal in order to achieve it. In this way, Miller is presenting the American Dream as a concept unable to change with time.

In both texts the Dream is presented as an all-consuming force. Regardless of the actual means of his success, Gatsby never seems to waver in his opinion of himself as an honest man, worthy of being loved.

In the play Death of a Salesman Willy immerses himself in a past where commerce and emotion were linked.

And both lack any real moral strength, which after all might be requisite for the achievement of the American Dream. Gatsby hurls lavish parties and lies about his background in an try to verify to Daisy that he is worthy of her.

He leans heavily on one lie in particular which is that he is "a success". The historical dream is the promise of a land of freedom with opportunity and equality for all. Similarly, Willy arrives dwelling to his family and brags about the sales he has made, when in truth, his boasts are meagre lies that he tells in alignment to be loved by his family and others.

How does the theme of the American Dream in Death Of A Salesman and The Great Gatsby compare?

He is not "well liked" as he wishes he was. This is the same sort of conceit shown by Willie Loman. When Willy and Gatsby go wrong to attain their dreams the only thing left for them to do is die. Throughout both works, Miller and Fitzgerald examine the theme of the vain pursuit of the American Dream.

Both Gatsby and Willy Loman neglect or fail to develop meaningful relationships because of their pursuit of the American Dream. His decision to commit suicide in order to provide his family with financial security demonstrates the emptiness of pursuing the American Dream.

Both are not only willing to lie, a bit, to achieve success, but both lie about He despairs, visibly, yet maintains that he is well-liked and he is a great salesman and father. In Death of a Salesman, Willie Loman lapses into nostalgic egoism, recalling past successes and greatly exaggerating them.

The writers present the unrestrained desire for money and pleasure as leading to corrupt methods of achieving the Dream.Tragic Heroes Willy Loman and Jay Gatsby # Usually of noble birth According to Aristotle tragic Heroes are Hamartia – a.k.a.

the tragic flaw that eventually leads to his downfall. They are passionate and thus commit many mistakes Peripeteia – a reversal of fortune brought. For Jay Gatsby, obtaining the material dream is a means to personal fulfilment, but for Willy Loman this concept is reversed: personal fulfilment is a means to obtaining the material dream.

Miller presents a confused dream through Willy Loman who cannot separate the issues of wealth and being “well liked”.

Compare and contrast Jay Gatsby and Willy Loman essaysThe Great Gatsby and Death of a Salesman Comparison Essay In The Great Gatsby, Jay Gatsby is the main character that believes in American Dream.

This characteristic is also identical to the characteristic of Willy Loman in Death of a Salesman be. Compare Death of a Salesman and The Great Gatsby. How do Willy Loman and Jay Gatsby suffer a similar fate?

Jay Gatsby Vs. Willy Loman

Answer: Although they lived very different lives - Willy, objectively a failure, and Gatsby, objectively a success - Willy and Gatsby had similar downfalls.

Get an answer for 'How does the theme of the American Dream in Death Of A Salesman and The Great Gatsby compare?' and find homework help for other Death of a Salesman questions at eNotes.

May 24,  · nicely in A Streetcar Named choose, Blanche DuBois distorts the actuality as does Jay Gatsby. He tries to stretch the actuality to make him look as though he has a extra advantageous existence than he has had to try Resolved.

Compare willie loman and jay gatsby
Rated 0/5 based on 70 review